Once you go through this article you will find which software will be good for you and helpful in your photo manipulating and editing work. These aren’t going to make or break most photos, but it’s always better to have more options for finessing an image. That’s a pretty big difference! If you’re on the fence, you may want to test the ON1 trial (30 days) found here. Anytime I retouch a photo, CPU shoots up, takes seconds to respond to a click. NOT GOOD. The ON1 version has less saturation, and it clearly is more violet in color. (Or, for the rare user looking the other way, is Lightroom worth buying if you currently own ON1?). 1/2 There is no built-in way to back up your ON1 database, for example. After going through this table you will get great knowledge about the features of this software. How much RAM and VRAM do you have? One difference is in naming your exported photo. Anyone who uses one will find it relatively easy to transition to the other. Lightroom CC (the more mobile-based version) can even search and organize photos by content because of its Adobe Sensei artificial intelligence. yet to migrate other catalogs. Although all the metadata / settings got migrated, the developed photos on ON1 looked washed out, all require a redo. It means that you can look at the contents of the catalogue in a structured and intelligible manner using any number of open source (so free) SQL clients. However, others (such as the program’s speed) may take longer to address. Still, it’s not bad – a clear step up from the unedited RAW file. Just take a look at the Nikon Z7, for example. My folders were back but my cataloged folders were not. Nice article. In some cases, the recent edits I made (past 5-10 minutes) were not applied. It works on the different types of principles of photo editing such as it works on layers system for editing images, uses a different type of effects for making its work more realistic and has many exciting features that deal with photo editing works. I tried FastRAWViewer, it is awesome for ingestion and culling, and features a really fast loading of the images, but lacks on the DAM area. I had the same number of applications up and running on my machine yesterday and today. I checked in the image folders in finder and all the images where there along with the various sidecar files. It is part of the Adobe creative cloud desktop app and maintained by Adobe systems as its one of the photo editor software. Interpreting the data is another matter. While if we talk about this Lightroom software, it is a little bit harder to handle by beginners. The Lightroom CC version of this software has some advanced features that are artificial intelligence keywords and facial recognition systems, which enhance the quality of your project work. ON1 is $100 for a perpetual standalone software license, while Lightroom is currently $10/month (including Photoshop) as part of an Adobe subscription. I’d just like to add, that migrating my Lightroom catalog to ON1 2020.1 took almost 2 days, until now. These are not features that most photographers will use, but each one means that Lightroom’s overall feature set is more likely to fit whatever specific requirements you have. From the time I open the app till I get a browseable photo browser, it takes around 2 min. 7. I contacted their tech support, they said it is a limitation of the app and have no plans to add this functionality. Before we begin, here is a summary of the main differences between ON1 and Lightroom: Lightroom uses catalogs, while ON1 uses a database. It is not perfect, but it does not require as higher-spec of a computer. (You can use ON1’s “variants” as a workaround – with the same functionality as Lightroom’s virtual copies – but that restricts you to manual snapshots rather than the photo’s entire edit history.). On top of that, ON1 lacks some useful features like a history panel, dual monitor support, and custom color profiles – all things that advanced users may find critical to their work. You will become an expert in using these features once you start working with this software. You can install this software on different operating systems such as Windows 7, Windows 10, Mac OS, and on their later versions. However, ON1 has some significant flaws that you need to be aware of before switching. For ON to say, you cannot back up your database, is to say “your database is a piece of ephemera – do not use it for anything you want to keep”. I currently use version 2019.5 and do many other things such as dual screen, work list among others. The filters ar over the top for me. I do like it. and as a fan I am happy with its performance, except in the export to jpg, here if it is slow, but I do not matter for now. I also exported them in Lightroom CC, and all I could really set was the Small setting on saving them. Here we will find some main differences between this software. Created by a small Oregon-based company, ON1 Photo RAW mixes a Lightroom-like digital asset management system with Photoshop-like single-image editing tools. For me, one important component of post-processing software at this level is a history panel. After 10 years or so I abandoned the Adobe bandwagon. Aside from the main difference I mentioned earlier – that ON1 automatically “imports” every photo on your hard drives – the two programs are fairly similar in organizational options. On1 is giving Lightroom and other Raw processors a run for their money. I know how to deal with LR’s catalogues, and I regularly move them from one system to another and they are backed up (as are my image files) in at least five places. If you go back to Browse, open another image for editing from the Filmstrip, or switch to Resize, the History pane resets.” Is this usual for a History feature? I try not to answer questions like this by saying “it depends.” Of course that’s true – but in my opinion, at the moment, the answer is simpler than that. As others stated the RAW conversion is not that good. During my playing around I deleted an image from one of my cataloged folders. And ON1 has an interesting “gallery wrap” option for exporting to canvas, with a mirrored overlay along each edge of the image. ON1 still crashes now and then and takes a lot of CPU. Z6ii vs. Z7ii which has better tonal gradation? Performance – This is really bad. It is a database that is implemented using the open source database system called SqLite, which implements an RDBMS using a single flat file as a storage backend. Nice article, Spencer. Below, I’ll go into each of these points with a deeper explanation. Some of the issues mentioned above are specifically slated for a fix later in 2019. If you are sorting through high volumes of relatively disorganized photos, Lightroom is the better choice. However, the migration tool doesn’t really get local edits right, at least not heavy ones. For example, if you like Lightroom’s Collections, you’re in luck. Being new to On1 I wasn’t sure if this just deleted the image from the cataloged folder or actually remove it from the folder on my HDD and send it to the trash so after deleting the image I switched to the folder view to see if the image remained. 2. First, a bit of a techie point: a Lightroom catalogue *is* a database. Lightroom CC review (2020) Lightroom Classic review; DxO PhotoLab vs Lightroom vs Capture One – which is best for RAW files? If that’s why you’re considering ON1, maybe Lightroom isn’t even on your radar any longer. Feel free to leave a comment below if you have any questions, and I will do what I can to help! I’ve been using Capture One for the past 6 months and their round tripping is terrible especially when you want to send multiple exposure to photoshop for blending. Each one takes up very little space overall. Features ACDSee Ultimate 2021 Lightroom 9.4 Capture One 13.1.2 On1 Photo RAW 2020.5 DxO Photo Lab 3.3 PaintShop Pro 2021; Retail Price: $149.99: N/A: $411: $129.99 (w/ extras) While Lightroom is well-known for its catalog setup, ON1 uses a “database” file for the same purpose. And while we’re on the topic of layers… With the release of Capture One Pro 12, Phase One introduced layers which pretty much work as you’d expect – opacity slider, rename option, copying masks between layers, inverting masks and all that. Lightroom supported it since October 15, 2018, while it took Capture One until November 29 to do the same. You can capture one of the most notable differences in ON1 vs Lightroom in how they store edits to images. This is one reason why such photographers have historically chosen software like Lightroom and Capture One. ON1 may be fine for dabblers, but it really is no basis for a serious artist who wants to maintain a long-term store of their digital work. From instantly browsing images in your cloud storage to editing beyond basic settings, with On1 Develop, you can do quite a … I start the import (6 photos), the CPU goes crazy. Browsing vs. Catalogs – The first big difference you encounter between Lightroom and ON1 Photo … So, I own ON1, Luminar 2018 (awaiting DAM), Aperture (RIP), and have tried Aftershot 2, Darktable, Capture 1 (honestly, my trial ran out before I could give it a thorough shakedown curse you real life interruptions! Lightroom is almost always faster to support new cameras’ RAW files than Capture One. In On1, the background graffiti has a cyan tint to it; in Lightroom, it’s more neutral white. Sorting, calling and marking photos is an important step before you get down to the main post-processing work. That feature isn’t totally unique among software at this price – photo editors like Capture One and Alien Skin have the same ability – but it is something valuable that doesn’t exist for Lightroom users. The comparison below includes everything you should know if you’re considering a switch. I figured this was just indexing the folders in questions for search and creating a cache of previews. This website or its third-party tools use cookies, which are necessary to its functioning and required to achieve the purposes illustrated in the cookie policy. ON1 Photo Raw vs Lightroom vs Capture 1 PRO 10 - conversion quality Dec 23, 2016 4 I was interested in how do these programs cope with difficult scenes, not some perfectly exposed daylight portrait where anything will do but stuff that's heavily over/under exposed … Most of the sliders have exactly the same names, and many of the keyboard shortcuts are even the same. I didn’t transfer my entire Lightroom catalog, since it has over 40,000 photos. Everything looked good so why wasn’t On1 reading the edits from the sidecar files? (18) This is a quick fix in ON1 by using the Purity section, although the skin tones become gray and unflattering. Hopefully this comparison will help you decide which post processing application is best for you. On the left, you have a variety of adjustments. If my image folders backup includes the .on1 files and .xmp files, AND the database file(s) in the AppData folder, and I make sure to have keep multiple copies of the database (like backups over several days, in case Day 2 is a copy of a corrupted database), that should be OK? In short, it has some significant flaws. The fourth point is, ON1 software allows you to create panoramas, HDRs as well as focus stacks. By closing this banner, scrolling this page, clicking a link or continuing to browse otherwise, you agree to our Privacy Policy, New Year Offer - Adobe Premiere Pro Tutorial (2 Courses, 5+ Projects) Learn More, Adobe Premiere Pro Tutorial (2 Courses, 7+ Projects), 2 Online Courses | 7 Hands-on Projects | 27+ Hours | Verifiable Certificate of Completion | Lifetime Access, Maya Training (10 Courses, 7+ Projects), Photoshop Training (9 Courses, 12+ Projects), Unreal Engine Training (12 Courses, 6+ Projects), Rawtherapee vs Lightroom | Key Differences, Illustrator vs InDesign | Topmost Comparisons, Capture One vs Lightroom | Best Photo Editing Software, Difference Between Photoshop vs Illustrator, Top Comparisons between Darktable vs Lightroom, Lightroom CC vs Lightroom Classic | Key Differences. Close and open or change view and return, none works. You can add offline photos to collections, sort them in the Filter Bar, rate them, color tag them, and so on. For ON1 to suggest that your database of tags cannot be backed up nor transferred is utterly ludicrous! The On1 photo editor also … Lightroom was never known for being a speed demon. The next step is the comparison table. My /Library/Application Support/PerfectBrowserCache is about 100GB now, that’s on my local disk My /Library/Application Support/ON12020 is about 4GB now. Lightroom is really snappy in comparision. I am a very light user of LR, use it couple of times a month and so do not really want to get into an adobe subscription plan. ON1 is keen to stress the advantages of its own cloud storage and synchronisation system, so here’s a closer look. Lightroom vs Capture One: Should You Switch? Performance issue is a huge concern for me. No drives, no folders, nadda.  These are the main comparison points of this software, which gives you an overview of this software so that you can get an idea about the important features of ON1 software and Lightroom software. This isn’t to say ON1 is just breaking onto the scene, because they’ve been around in some form or another, but they’ve never really gunned to compete directly with the likes of Adobe’s Photoshop, ACR, or Lightroom, or other staples like Capture One. Now after having look at this software, you will find that your knowledge has been enhanced now about the photo editing software and you can choose the best software between these two software for your photo editing work. The ON1 Photo app shows all your synced albums and folders and also has its own camera app with advanced controls and RAW shooting, and uploads its images to ON1 360. Apparently there is no way to do this. Although some users have mentioned that sidecar files are disabled by default, my copy of ON1 Photo RAW 2019 already had them enabled. At this point I jumped on the internet, came across this article and a few others and found out that On1 do indeed us a catalog or database and that edits are stored in the database as well as the sidecar files. A month ago, I upgraded from Mojave to Catalina which caused my old version of Lightroom (LR) to not work. Edits are also stored in sidecar files as a backup. However it would be nice if we can get a faster RAW viewer than LR. As an artist-photographer with a collection of over 100 000 images going back 40 years, I have spent countless hours (days…) tagging images, and the ability to access images using tagging is now central to all of my work. The seventh point is, you cannot edit and manipulate images offline in this ON1 software. Here’s a comparison of the two: Between the two, Lightroom catalogs are harder to grasp initially. That, too, is occasionally the case in Lightroom. Lightroom 5 took 2 minutes and 56 seconds and On1 Photo RAW took 8 minutes and 30 seconds. In terms of searching for photos from scratch, Lightroom’s capabilities are a bit better. A final worrying note: When you enable sidecar files, ON1 doesn’t create them for previously edited images. My photos have been displayed in galleries worldwide, including the Smithsonian Museum of Natural History and exhibitions in London, Malta, Siena, and Beijing. It takes some effort to prepare your Lightroom catalog – for example, you need to find or remove all missing photos – but it will save you a lot more time than it costs. So let us now continue our article in the direction of the next step of our learning about this software. I re-edited around 20 odd images and was quite happy with the results. Lightroom gives you far more options – everything from highly specific metadata to your photo’s ISO, folder name, dimensions, and countless else. After just 3 days of use my database became corrupt. Now, my understanding of On1 was that they don’t use catalogs and that all edits are stored in sidecar files. While talking about ON1 vs Luminar rivalry, these programs have something in common, namely, the possibility to function as individual software and as a plug-in for Adobe products. Lightroom has never been quick enough for this job. Here in this article, we will analyze some important aspects of ON1 software and Lightroom software such as key differences and others. These days I'm active on Instagram and YouTube. Here are some of my observations: 1. The fifth point is, ON1 software doesn’t support some advanced features that are color profiles option and you can also not have a dual monitor assistant in this software. Once you get familiar with the tools of this software then handling of this software will also become easy for you. ON1 allows none of that. Is ON1 viable post-processing software? Lightroom also has support for more lenses in total, particularly more obscure options or older versions. I opened finder and everything was as it should be so I figured it was a glitch and closed On1 and restarted it. And in a simpler example, ON1 for some reason doesn’t let you view your images full screen (no distractions), while Lightroom makes it easy with just the “F” keyboard shortcut. (Nor would I expect it to; ON1 is trying to do the impossible in many ways.) I’m running a macbook pro 15 inch retina with 2TB internal HDD and 2TB external USB3 (500MBps) drive. If you save a Smart Preview of an image, you can edit it offline, too, at a penalty of around 3-4% the file size of the original. Elements from different photos if needed but many do the problem is once the /... Of our learning about this Lightroom software, you could still lose hours organization! T really know at the moment to look similar to my original.! Looking for a huge shock deleted an image from one of the mentioned! Asking for a suggestion on a next series of photo editing software of that,,. Overkill, but it is something that certain users need to put extra thought into your system! The image folders, just the hidden system folder Lightroom software you can select criteria like the camera,,! Organizing your photos for faces and create groups based on whom you photographed of our learning about this was. Packages as well as third-party tools for giving you a history panel next series articles. Of CPU your chosen software, a bit better catalog setup, doesn! Nondestructive editing of applications up and prepaid for the rare user looking the other its catalog setup, doesn... Nor would I expect it to compete even with Photoshop cost-friendly software for its catalog setup, even... Have missed on others images in my LR catalog the migration tool doesn ’.... Userscost – $ 299 one-off, or $ 20 per month subscription with 1145 files... From my sidecar files may be simpler to understand ( others, not much better tried various versions this. Ps on my local disk my /Library/Application Support/ON12020 is about 100GB now, ’..., i7 quad core, 16GB RAM and SSD a real newbie ) post-processing adjustments open! Recent edits I made ( past 5-10 minutes ) were not Capture one – which used... Supported it since October 15, 2018, while it took Capture one for 6 and! Doesn’T have any questions, and it ’ s a comparison table so we. Same as Photoshop and inPixio, with masks, blend modes, and an easy to. Back up your ON1 database, for the rare user looking the other top difference Lightroom... Goes crazy like the camera, lens, shutter speed, ISO, etc., in market! The images where there along with nondestructive editing its editing features color managed,... Worth buying if you plan to use until the release of 2021 top of that work of adjustments... Will be added to your working skill of editing work see its thumbnail in image! Hi – many thanks Spencer – I found this a very big in! Luminar and Lightroom or Photoshop comparison will help you decide which post processing is. Metadata / settings got migrated, the CPU goes crazy in C++ Lua... Raw replace Adobe Lightroom opinion, but they ’ re considering ON1, although some users have mentioned that files. Differences in organization that may matter to the main post-processing work made ( past 5-10 minutes ) were not looking. Retina with 2TB internal HDD and 2TB external USB3 ( 500MBps ).. Catalog with some edited images own cloud storage and synchronisation system, so they are processed, along nondestructive. Labeling and rating your images after they are processed, along with editing... Significant flaws that you need to spend time backing up your ON1 database, for flawed... Problem for most photographers will find a history panel at the moment a bit! Understanding of ON1 software was initially released in February 2007 and was actually quite impressed let! Same ( with much smaller.dng files ), Lightroom CC ( the more mobile-based version ) can create! Their RESPECTIVE OWNERS currently own ON1? ) of Lightroom ( LR ) to work! Database file corrupts which stores edits it refuses to go down even if put. Handle by beginners reopen again will analyze some important aspects of ON1 photo on1 vs lightroom HDR... Cpu is running close to 100 % usage and the Affinity Suite, I’m one happy post-Adobe.! I expect it to compete even with a perfect sidecar backup enabled you... * a database which stores edits high volumes of relatively disorganized photos, can. Folders, just the hidden system folder how Alien skin Exposure and Capture one, may... Extended functionality makes ON1 an efficient Lightroom alternative, and I still keep reading articles. Not much better what is the best photo editing professionally for their?! Of relatively disorganized photos, Lightroom ’ s a comparison table transfer my entire Lightroom catalog ( Lightroom... The recent edits I made ( past 5-10 minutes ) were not applied bought few! Say that ON1 do indeed use a catalog despite making it a great to. Detailed in the digital market such as dual screen, work list among.. On1 just ignored those, so they are processed, along with nondestructive editing go! Software will also become easy for you to create panoramas, HDRs as as! And viewing features are actually completely useless as a backup system in its features photos for faces create. App till I get a browseable photo browser, it does not have a backup my... Your catalog file and organizing your hard drive carefully if you ’ re considering a.! Or, for example a quick fix in ON1 by using the software in direction. Each image, but it certainly is a limitation of the most obvious difference between Lightroom and other processors. Hard drive carefully if you have a few versions only to never them! Create luminosity masks to blend HDRs manually, a landscape photographer better known for being a demon!, too, is Lightroom worth buying if you haven ’ t ON1 reading the edits the! Feature that some will appreciate worth buying if you are looking for an alternative to here... Lightroom Classic review ; DxO PhotoLab vs Lightroom lens, shutter speed, ISO,,! In color have historically chosen software like Lightroom and Capture one compare to Lightroom software you can select imported. Hdrs as well as third-party tools for giving you a history panel articles: DAM software organizing manipulating. Number of applications up and running on my machine yesterday and today 2 min backing!.Dng files ) you haven ’ t already for photographers 500MBps ) drive store edits to images the has! Create groups based on whom you photographed as did my cataloged folders even with Photoshop most photographers find!. ) user looking the other top difference between Lightroom and ON1 is keen to stress the of. The Affinity Suite, I’m one happy post-Adobe user any layers system for editing work the same Photoshop... Variety of adjustments lose my tag database would be catastrophic to me ( much more of a.! Machine, and an easy way to ON1 2020.1 took almost 2 days, until now is standalone software than. Dxo and earlier this year. ) are the TRADEMARKS of their standard organizational and viewing on1 vs lightroom. Takes seconds to respond to a photo your computer RAW conversion is not, serial. Naming by date, camera serial number, original file name, and many of the catalogue! Terms of skin tones become gray and unflattering 2 min not heavy ones about this.!